|
Microsoft
Alternatives
Microsoft has made it very easy for consultants to use its products
by default. In most cases, it makes sense to use the industry standard
software packages for simpler file sharing, to make it easy for a
new consultant to step in and take over, …etc. As good consultants,
however, we would be remiss if we didn't at least let our clients
know of the alternatives and even recommend them if the situation
warrants it. Since Microsoft software covers several arenas, we have
decided to spread this info over the next three issues of the Promethean:
April - Part I - Server Operating System (OS) Alternatives
May - Part II - Desktop Applications
June - Part III - Internet Connectivity and Browsing
Applications
Part I - Server OS Alternatives
We are probably all familiar with Microsoft's very powerful networking
software, Windows 2000, or it's predecessor Windows NT. Some of
the alternatives that you may or may not hear about are:
I. Novell
NetWare
Novell NetWare
was Microsoft's main competition in the Server OS department for
many years. NetWare had a sizeable head start with its OS and has
been formidable competition since the early days of MS LAN Manager
(Microsoft's first networking software), but it seems to have lost
ground with its last few versions. Version 6.0 is getting better
press, however, and some costly licensing moves on Microsoft's behalf
have caused some migration back to NetWare and UNIX. Still, NetWare's
market share has fallen from over 70% in the early 1990's to around
17% today. Microsoft jumped out in front with Windows NT Server
in 1995 and now enjoys a comfortable margin over all competitors.
This kind of
loss in market share would normally suggest that superior products
gained foothold, but one must consider Microsoft's marketing muscle
and penchant for incorporating the good ideas of others into its
products (many call this thievery).
Some of the
advantages of Novell NetWare are:
1. Simpler/cheaper
licensing
2. Fewer security concerns
3. More support for multiprocessor environments and server clustering
Some of the disadvantages of Novell NetWare are:
1. Many desktop applications do not work as well with NetWare
2. Because it
has less market share, third-party developers often conduct less
testing with NetWare
3. It is much
easier to find Microsoft Certified System Engineers (MCSE's) than
it is to find Certified Novell Engineers (CNE's) to support your
network
II. UNIX
(Linux)
UNIX is a popular multi-user, multitasking operating system developed
at Bell Labs in the early 1970s. UNIX was designed to be a small,
flexible system used exclusively by programmers. Bell Labs distributed
the operating system in its source language form, so anyone who
obtained a copy could modify and customize it for his own purposes.
By the end of the 1970s, dozens of different versions of UNIX were
running at various sites. Of course this has led to difficulties
trying to define standards.
With its newer
cousin, Linux, UNIX has regained its second-place position in the
network operating system market behind Microsoft.
Some of the advantages of UNIX are:
1. Inexpensive
(often free)
2. Extremely
stable
Some of the
disadvantages of UNIX are:
1. Not user
friendly (GUI interfaces like MOTIF are still new to UNIX)
2. Support very
hard to find
3. Fewer "Off-the-Shelf"
packages written for UNIX
If you have questions regarding the products mentioned above and
how they might be applied to your computer network, please call
us at
317/733-2388.
|